How Much Should You Offer on a House?

You have found a property you love. The location is right, the layout works and you can already picture yourself living there.

Then comes the difficult question. How much should you actually offer?

Do you offer the asking price, start lower and negotiate or offer more because other buyers are interested?

At Healthy Financial Services, we combine extensive estate agency experience with mortgage advice, so we understand how easily emotions can influence these decisions.

There is no single formula for deciding what to offer, but there are several things worth considering before committing to what could be the biggest purchase of your life.

Is the Asking Price Realistic?

One of the biggest misconceptions among buyers is that the asking price represents a property's true value.

It doesn't necessarily.

The asking price is what the seller and estate agent have decided to market the property for. Sometimes it is realistic, sometimes optimistic and occasionally deliberately set to attract competition.

A property advertised at £400,000 is not automatically worth £400,000.

Before making an offer, look at what comparable properties have actually sold for, rather than relying entirely on advertised prices.

Consider their size, condition, location and any improvements. You can check previous sales through HM Land Registry, although the most recent transactions may not yet appear.

How Long Has the Property Been on the Market?

A property's marketing history can tell you quite a lot.

A home that has only been advertised for a few days may attract strong interest, particularly if competitively priced.

But what about one that has been available for four months?

Has the asking price been reduced? Has a previous sale fallen through? Is the seller motivated to move quickly?

None of these automatically means there is something wrong with the property, but they are useful questions to ask.

From our estate agency experience, understanding the circumstances behind a sale can be just as important as understanding the property itself.

Should You Offer Below the Asking Price?

There is nothing wrong with offering below the asking price, provided you have a reason for doing so.

However, we would be cautious about following blanket advice to always offer 5% or 10% less.

Every property and every seller is different.

If comparable homes have sold for less, the property requires significant work or it has been on the market for some time, a lower offer may be reasonable.

Equally, offering substantially less on a competitively priced property could mean missing out.

The objective should not simply be to secure the biggest discount. It should be to buy the right property at a price that makes financial sense.

Your Position as a Buyer Matters Too

The highest offer does not always win.

Imagine a seller receives two offers.

One buyer offers the full asking price but still needs to sell their existing property.

Another offers slightly less, already has a Decision in Principle and is chain-free.

Depending on the seller's circumstances, the second offer could be more attractive.

This is why we encourage buyers to establish their mortgage position before making offers.

A Decision in Principle can indicate what you may be able to borrow, although it is not a guarantee of mortgage approval.

Understanding how much you can comfortably afford and being ready to proceed can strengthen your position when negotiating.

Don't Let Competition Push You Beyond Your Budget

Buying a property can become surprisingly emotional, particularly when other buyers are interested.

You might be asked to submit your best and final offer or increase your original figure.

Before doing so, consider whether you would still be comfortable paying that amount once the excitement has settled.

Remember that the purchase price is only part of the overall cost. Stamp Duty, conveyancing fees, surveys, moving expenses and potential repairs all need to be considered.

Your mortgage lender could also value the property below the agreed purchase price, affecting the mortgage available and potentially requiring a larger deposit.

Just because you can afford to offer more does not necessarily mean you should.

How Healthy Financial Services Can Help

Most people associate a mortgage adviser with finding a competitive mortgage rate, but arranging the finance is only one part of buying a home.

At Healthy Financial Services, we combine whole-of-market mortgage advice with property buying support, drawing on our extensive estate agency experience.

Using tools such as Sprift, we can help clients research properties, review comparable sales, understand local market information and consider how to approach an offer.

That might mean recognising when a property appears fairly priced, identifying reasons to negotiate or understanding the financial implications of offering more.

Sometimes the right decision is to make a strong offer. Sometimes it is to negotiate. And occasionally, it is to walk away.

Our aim is not simply to help you secure a mortgage, but to help you make a more informed decision about the property you are buying.

If you are considering buying a home in Reading, Berkshire, Oxfordshire, Buckinghamshire or further afield, book a free initial consultation to discuss your plans and how we can help.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute personalised mortgage or property valuation advice.

Property research and negotiation support are not FCA-regulated services and do not benefit from the same regulatory protections as mortgage advice.

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

Next
Next

Oxford Half Marathon 2026: Running for Thames Valley Air Ambulance